Archif Dyddiol: 30 Ebrill 2017

Ifan Morgan Jones: Plaid has problems – but Leanne isn’t one

Leanne Woood
The past few days have seen renewed speculation in the press and social media about Leanne Wood’s leadership.

This happens to all leaders after a few years in the top job. But to borrow an idiom from the Welsh language, Leanne Wood has pulled this bees’ nest on to her own head.

Plaid’s rules state that MPs can’t lead the party, and by deciding (unnecessarily) to announce that she was considering standing in Rhondda, she turned everyone’s attention to what a future leadership election could look like.

If Plaid Cymru do fail to make significant headway on June 8th (not winning Ynys Môfor instance) the clamour could intensify quite significantly.

However, I think that Plaid Cymru members should quell their revolutionary fervour (in this one instance). Not all the parties’ woes can be blamed on the leader, and ditching Leanne may not be in their long-term interest.

Welsh nationalist tend to be more susceptible than others to dreaming of a man gwyn man draw. But the triban is not always greener on the other side.

Leanne Wood is a) well-known throughout Wales and b) popular (by the standards of other Welsh and UK politicians). She also secured a genuine, gold-plated breakthrough by winning a seat in the valleys, where Plaid has been knocking on the door without success for many years. These are three things not many Plaid leaders have achieved.

The truth is that not making significant headway in the General Election would not be the end of the world for Plaid Cymru. Their real aim is and should be to secure a breakthrough at the National Assembly Elections. And recent polls suggest that, if Labour’s woes continue, they would be well-placed to do so in a few years’ time.

If Plaid Cymru were hotly contesting four or five seats in the valleys at the next election, who would be better to lead the party than Rhondda’s visible and popular Assembly Member?

Plaid’s problems are more complex

Discussions about changing the leadership of Paid Cymru also miss the larger picture, which is that because they are a Welsh nationalist party, their problems can’t easily be fixed with a change of personnel as they would be in the case of other, British nationalist parties.

If Labour changed leadership and moderated their hard-left stance they would no doubt bounce back in the polls. But that’s because they’re very much part of a dominant British establishment that includes the media and other institutions who would warmly welcome them back into the fold.

Plaid’s problem is ultimately that they’re a nationalist party in a country that isn’t particularly conducive to nationalism.

Plaid Cymru supporters look enviously at Scotland. But despite Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon’s talents, Scotland has the advantage of having strong national institutions and a comparatively healthy media.

I tend to think that nationalists in Wales place too much of a burden on Plaid Cymru’s shoulders. Political parties are constrained by the need to maintain the public’s support. Thus, they’re naturally risk averse.

Other political parties have proxies in the media, think tanks and other institutions that can do the hard (and sometimes dirty) work of changing minds for them without having to worry about a backlash at the ballot box.

Welsh nationalists need to concentrate on setting these up rather than sniping at Plaid’s leadership. Blaming Plaid can become an excuse for inaction.

Ultimately, whatever her decision (and she may herself be ready to give up the leadership for entirely personal reasons – it is a tough job) I hope Leanne Wood stays on as a Plaid Cymru AM.

Being a credible government in waiting is about more than just the leader. You need a strong cabinet in waiting too, and having Leanne on the team would show that Plaid has a lot of strength in depth.

Parhau i ddarllen

BlogMenai.com: Byth yn dysgu

Mae Golwg360 wedi penderfynu arwai yr arlwy heddiw efo ‘pol piniwn’  sy’n awgrymu bod y Toriaid yn gwneud yn anhygoel o dda yng Nghymru a phawb arall yn sal iawn.  Fel mae digwyddiadau diweddar wedi dangos mae angen cymryd gofal gyda pholiau … Parhau i ddarllen

Gofalaeth Fro'r Llechen Las: Nid collwyr mohonom

Mae’n dymor etholiad. Yn Ffrainc, maen nhw ar ganol ethol Arlywydd. Yma, mae’n Etholiad y Cyngor Sir ddydd Iau.  Ymhen mis cawn Etholiad Cyffredinol arall, ac fe ganwn: Daw hyfryd fis, Mehefin cyn bo hir,  A dyma brysurdeb  Etholiad yn ein tir.    Braf yn ein tir,  Braf yn ein tir,  Cyffro, cyffro, cyffro’r Etholiad […] Parhau i ddarllen

Pop Cymru: Torpido EP – Lastigband – allan rwan

Torpido by LastigbandAr gael rwan o recordiau Cae Gwyn EP newyddTorpido EP – Lastigband Parhau i ddarllen

Pop Cymru: Ffrwydrad Tawel – Ani Glass i’w gael yn ddigidol

Os fuoch chi mor anlwcus a ni i fethu cael eich gafael ar becyn nifer cyfyngedig o waith Ani Glass, peidiwch a phoeni.

Gallwng rwan brynu copi digidol o Ffrwydrad Tawel sydd yn cynnwys PDF o waith celf Ani a chopi MP3 o’r caneuon.

Prynwch yma:

Parhau i ddarllen

Gwefan Capel Salem, Dolgellau: Taflen mis Mai ar gael yn awr

I weld taflen mis Mai cliciwch ar y ddolen Parhau i ddarllen

Blog Glyn Adda: Yn iach ymenyn glân !

Fe awn ni heibio heddiw i Trump a Gogledd Corea, i dryblith y Dwyrain Canol, i Theresa a Merkel a Le Pen, i ddyfodol cyfansoddiadol Ynys Brydain ac Iwerddon, a hyd yn oed i’r pwnc pwysicaf oll i ni Gymry’r dwthwn hwn sef polisi cynllunio Gwynedd a Môn, ac fe gymerwn dro bach i’r hen […] Parhau i ddarllen

Asturias yn Gymraeg: Troedio’r Grawnwin

Troedio’r ffrwyth, mewn pwll neu faddon, oedd y dull gwreiddiol o wasgu sudd y grawnwin ar gyfer gwneud gwin. Mae e dal i’w weld mewn sawl man o’r byd, fel atyniad i ymwelwyr gan fwyaf – ac yn aml mae cyfle i gymryd rhan. Yn ardal gwinoedd Rioja, ac yn enwedig ar y ffin rhwng […] Parhau i ddarllen

atgof.co: O’r Corau i Coburn